Categories: PenguinPoop

Are the Penguins the 2017-18 Blackhawks?

Entering the 2017-18 season, the Chicago Blackhawks had ample reason to be optimistic. Only two seasons removed from their third Stanley Cup over a glorious six-year run, they’d won 50 games the season before.

Superstars Patrick Kane and Jonathan Toews were 29 years old and in their respective primes. Although a touch long in the tooth, two-time Norris Trophy winner Duncan Keith and stay-at-home stud Brent Seabrook were still highly effective defensemen, buttressed by Corey Crawford, a two-time Jennings Trophy winner, between the pipes.

Power forward and Pittsburgh native Brandon Saad had returned following a two-year hiatus. The Hawks boasted a stable of rising young stars, including Nick Schmaltz, scrappy Ryan Hartman and pocket-sized sniper Alex DeBrincat, who’d go on to notch 28 goals as a rookie. Artem Anisimov and Patrick Sharp provided veteran depth.

Behind the bench…the dean of NHL coaches Joel Quenneville.

Oh, the team also featured a 27-year-old rookie defenseman out of Czechia named Jan Rutta.

Following an uneven start that included an uncharacteristic five-game losing streak, the Blackhawks appeared to right the ship with a five-game winning streak in December to run their record to a respectable 17-11-5.

Then disaster struck. Crawford, who’d been carrying the team (a sterling .929 save percentage), suffered a season-ending upper-body injury on December 23. The Hawks went 16-28-5 the rest of the way, snapping a run of nine-straight postseason appearances.

With the exception of a Covid induced “everybody gets in” postseason berth in 2020, the Hawks have missed the playoffs four of the past five seasons.

And now? With the worst record in the league, the Hawks are in complete teardown mode. A rebuild could take years…years. Although greatly diminished, Kane and Toews are still there (at least for now), a pair of twin 34-year-old pillars standing squarely amid the gutted ruins of a once-proud champion.

I look at the Hawks gradual fade-turned-cliff-dive and shudder. Does a similar apocalyptic fate await our beloved Penguins?

My heart pleads no but my gut screams yes.

We’re not playing good hockey right now. Indeed, we’re on a 0-4-2 losing jag, our second extended skid of the relatively young campaign.

A temporary glitch you say? My crystal ball says different.

With the exception of an occasional burst here and there, we’re no longer capable of playing the style of hockey that won us two Stanley Cups. The team’s aging, injuries are mounting and there isn’t enough organizational depth to patch the gaping holes. Indeed, with the possible exception of forwards Drew O’Connor, Filip Hallander and Valtteri Puustinen the immediate prospect cupboard is decidedly bare. There aren’t any future Sidney Crosbys or even Bryan Rusts on the way.

Worse yet, goalie Tristan Jarry, the driving force behind an early 15-3-2 hot streak, is out with a lower-body injury. Shades of Crawford in Chi-town.

It doesn’t paint a pretty picture, especially given the quality of competition in the murderous Metro and the Eastern Conference overall. Sharks are circling our tattered playoff aspirations from above (the ‘Canes, Devils, Capitals, Rangers and Islanders) and below (the improving Sabres). Even our heretofore sad-sack state mates, the Flyers, are gaining ground.

Jammed tight against the cap, GM Ron Hextall isn’t likely to swing an impact trade along the lines of the Jeff Carter and Rickard Rakell acquisitions of the past to lift the team out of the doldrums, at least not without sacrificing quality and/or draft picks in return.

What we have is pretty much what we have.

Again, it paints a grisly picture, for the immediate future but especially down the road. A fading team manacled to a collection of long-term contracts given to 30-something stars that I, for the record, was in favor of. All the while sliding toward our inexorable doom.

I close my eyes and glimpse Sid and Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang standing amid the rubble, just as Kane and Toews are in Chicago, the siren’s wail from Black Sabbath’s War Pigs providing the soundtrack for a bleak hockey future.

Rick Buker

View Comments

  • Hey Jim,

    And there in lies the problem - ego. Management, the media, and the fans have been too afraid to take a critical look at the team they shouted down those that could see so as not to bruise their fragile egos. Now, rather than a short retool, like Chi we are in for a long rebuild, and unless we are lucky enough to snare another generational talent, longer than Chi will take to become relevant again. I say this because there are still too many people blinding themselves to the truth.

  • Hey Rick,

    Interesting Article. I understand why/what you are saying but I would say our Pens may be in a worse situation than the Hawks. As you noted Kane and Toews were in still in their 20, Crosby and Malkin are well past that. Furthermore, Jarry has been very inconsistent. Part of the problem is that he has been very weak on HDSA. Out of the 71 Goalies in the League not below 1 Standard Deviation of the mean, Jarry ranks 40th in HDSv%, the bottom half of the league. Making matters worse he ranks 28th in terms of most HDSA faced , the top half of the league. That makes for the worst of both worlds. Not only would he need to pick up his game, when facing HDSA but his defenders need to tighten down on theirs.

    If you were to think back, I was perhaps the 1st here on Penguin Poop to believe in the 2015-2016 team. While almost all readers were down on the team until the playoffs started, I started believing in February. a couple of years later I was again at the front end of the curve with Jim, seeing that the days of glory was about to be over if management didn't take off their rose colored glasses. Management didn't and here we are.

    I don't believe in absolute statements. I look at things in terms of probabilities. I will not say that our Pens won't turn the train around. However, the probabilities are very, very small.

    • Well said Coach...
      It is not a matter of wanting to win. Of course we all want our team to win. The real question is can they win ! The last 4 years gives me a pretty good answer. There is a slight chance the Pen's might win it all in 2023 but I would not bet on it.
      Heck there is a better chance I could get struck by lighting too but I highly doubt it.
      We are not that top 4-5 play off team any more and that is what happened to Chicago. The reality of their sad situation and the hype of the local media and the local fans keep spreading the "We are the Champions " bull crap.
      We are the same way I am afraid to say.
      Cheers
      JIM

Recent Posts

Penguins Update: Drafting Franchise Players a Luck of the Draw

As the Penguins’ fortunes spiral down, down, down to where Gollum and the San Jose…

20 hours ago

A Shot in the Dark: Penguins Blow Lead (Again), Lose to Lightning in OT

For our bumbling Penguins, the more things change, the more they stay the same. In…

2 days ago

NHL Update: Bruins Fire Montgomery

Less than two seasons after he guided Boston to a record setting 135-point season, the…

3 days ago

Penguins This ‘n’ ‘At

With nothing in particular to write about, I thought I’d scrape a few random thoughts…

3 days ago

Shark-Bait No More, Penguins Escape with 4-3 Shootout Win

I apologize ahead of time for the brevity and lateness of this recap, especially in…

5 days ago

Penguins Rally, Then Collapse in Dismal 6-2 Loss to CBJ

I usually have some idea of how I want to approach my PP posts. Well,…

6 days ago