Categories: PenguinPoop

Surprise, Surprise (Surprise), Penguins Lose to ‘Canes

Contrary to Gomer Pyle’s favorite saying, it came as no great surprise that the Penguins fell to the Carolina Hurricanes last night in Raleigh by a 2-1 count. After all, we finished the season 0-2-2 against our nettlesome Metro rival, in the process garnering only two out of a possible eight points.

Nor is it a great surprise how it happened. As they are wont to do under coach Rod Brind’Amour, the aptly named Hurricanes rolled over us like a cyclonic storm surge, shooting pucks from everywhere while piling up significant advantages in shot attempts (33-19), shots on goal (15-11) and, most significantly, scoring chances (a whopping 21-5) during the opening 20 minutes.

What did come as a bit of a surprise? We managed to limit them to a lone goal on a wide-open look by Brady Skjei from the left circle at 17:02.

The second period? Lather, rinse, repeat. While the Pens misfired on three power-play opportunities, including a two-man advantage near the end of the frame courtesy of old friend Jordan Staal, the ‘Canes controlled the action and tacked on a second goal by Vancouver refugee Jalen Chatfield mid-period.

Surprise number three? Despite playing their second game in two nights, our undermanned Pens found their legs and dominated the third period, especially after Rickard Rakell potted a gift power-play goal at 7:48 off a brain cramp clearing swipe by goalie Frederik Andersen.

Try as they might, our guys just couldn’t push the equalizer past the big Swedish netminder.

Thank the dear Lord we’re done with the ‘Canes.

Puckpourri

Courtesy of the Pens’ third-period push, shot attempts (65-65) and shots on goal (36-35 in favor of the ‘Canes) were just about even. Our hosts still held a sizeable edge in scoring chances (40-30), high-danger chances (19-13) and faceoffs (56 percent).

The score could’ve been much worse were it not for a redemptive performance from Casey DeSmith, who turned aside 34 of 36 shots.

Speaking of redemptive efforts, following an awful game the night before the Evgeni Malkin line bounced back with a vengeance (Corsi of 60). Jason Zucker nearly staked us to an early lead four minutes in, but his sizzling wrister struck iron. In the opening seconds of the third period, Geno turned Brent Burns into a lamp post but couldn’t beat Andersen.

With Marcus Pettersson still out with an illness, the Pens were down arguably their top three d-men, a development that’s hampered our transition game. Which leads me to…

Missing Pieces

Injuries have hit our Pens with almost surgical efficiency, in the process removing some key components from our lineup.

Record-wise, Tristan Jarry’s absence has been the most damaging, perhaps followed in importance by Jeff Petry’s. Here are the Pens won-lost records among the players currently MIA.

Player

Position

Record With

Record Without

Tristan Jarry

G

15-5-4

6-10-2

Josh Archibald

RW

18-8-4

3-7-2

Jeff Petry

D

16-8-4

5-7-2

Ryan Poehling

LW/C

17-10-4

4-5-2

Kris Letang

D

15-10-4

6-5-2

The injuries to fourth-liners Josh Archibald and Ryan Poehling have also been telling, stripping away a much-needed underpinning of speed and grit.

Notice I haven’t mentioned Sidney Crosby in my last two game summaries?

Shake the Jake?

On the surface, forward Jake Guentzel is enjoying a strong season. In 38 games, he’s got 17 goals and 37 points, nearly a point-per-game clip. Combined with his boyish looks and skilled, clever play, he’s exceedingly popular in the ‘Burgh. “Jakes Shakes” and all that.

However, upon closer examination, he isn’t having all that great of a season. Over his past nine games, he’s got two goals and two assists, all collected in a two-game cluster. Since December 1, he’s tallied five goals in 18 games. Rather pedestrian output for a top-line winger.

Five of his goals have come on the power play, five more are empty-netters. He ranks seventh on the team in 5v5 goals with six, which puts him outside the top-six group.

Meanwhile, the Pens’ mix is as stale as month-old bread and just as bland.

I propose using Jake as the center piece of a trade. In my dreams I’d love to pry Islanders captain Anders Lee off Long Island.

A horse at 6’3” and 235 pounds, Lee would add a much-needed power element and net-front presence. While not quite in Guentzel’s class as a scorer, with 15 goals and 30 points in 44 games he’s no slouch, either.

Are there downsides to such a swap?

Sure.

For starters, Lee has a cap hit of $7 million, $1 million over Guentzel’s rate, and he’s signed for three more seasons after this one. At 32 years of age, he’s four years Jakes’ senior and would further age our team. And deals between division rivals are rare, especially ones competing for the same playoff spot.

But the Isles have long sought a volatile talent to team with Matt Barzal, and the Pens could desperately use a player with Lee’s physical stature and attributes, not to mention leadership qualities.

Kind of a latter-day Mark Recchi-for-Rick Tocchet swap.

I’m not saying it wouldn’t be a gamble. But given the Pens uninspired play of late (2-6-2 in our last 10 games), some kind of shakeup is in order. If not sooner than perhaps at the trade deadline.

On Tap

Speaking of the Isles (23-18-3, 49 points), they leapfrogged over us (21-15-6, 48 points) and into the final Eastern Conference playoff spot.

Don’t look now, but John Tortorella’s improving Flyers (18-18-7, 43 points) are on a 7-1 roll, including a pair of victories over the previously white-hot Capitals.

Up next, lowly Anaheim at PPG Paints Arena on Monday night. Hopefully our Pens can dine on a little Duck soup (pun intended).

Rick Buker

View Comments

  • Hey Rick,

    I have to get this off my chest;

    You want to know how you can tell when a team is an also ran?
    Their fans celebrate almost wins.

    I know, that's harsh, but it is no joke. Winnipeg came into Pgh in game 3 in 4 nights and cleaned our clock. That is what winners do.

    *Tristan Jarry? his Sv% is 16th in league, 16th. He is average! Missing him hurting the team? not really a loss.
    *Archibald? 3 G and no Primary and with a TGF of 2.12? not really a loss.
    *Jeff Petry? We are struggling without him, but really? almost any other team would not miss him.
    *Ryan Poehling? He is having a good season but he is a 4th liner.
    *Kris Letang? Maybe years ago, but this year, ah no.

    When a team misses players having these average to poor season, they have far, far more problems.

    Trade Jake? Everyone is tradable. But the big question now becomes, how will trading Jake improve the team this season? If he is traded, who will fill the hole trading him creates? Or will it be at best another Matheson for Petrie trade, nothing more than lateral move.

    I know I am being pessimistic but I just don't feel like trying to pretend the glass is half full.

    • Hey Other Rick,

      While I can appreciate where you're coming from, I take a more simplistic view. Guys like Jarry, Petry, Archibald and Poehling (and Letang) were helping the team win, and that's the bottom line.

      I think to judge Jarry solely on terms of save percentage is being a bit narrow. Petry was serving as a glue guy on defense and playing a pretty solid all-around game. Along with Teddy Blueger, Archibald and Poehling were an effective fourth line that provided some sand, speed and energy, along with some fine penalty killing. There's value in that.

      Plus, I think these guys provide intangibles that can't be measured on a slide rule.

      Are we a Stanley Cup contender with them in the lineup? No. But with them, we're at least a decent hockey team. And, in my mind, there's no question we miss them.

      Rick

      • Hey Rick,

        First I do apologize, the Penguins current state left me so frustrated that I forgot to say great lead in.
        Gomer Pyle and Sgt Carter were staples.

        As for the Penguins, sorry, there is a HUGE reason why we lost, even when we are at full strength with Archibald, Poehling, Letang, Jarry, and Petry, we are average. None of the above players are above the league average in any results. Even Crosby, Malkin, and Guentzel are just a tad above average.

      • PS-Regarding Guentzel, I sure don't hate him. Despite his smallish frame, he competes as hard as anybody, at least in the offensive zone, and he's fearless (and smart) about the way he plays in traffic.

        On the flip side, he's a terrible defensive player (2% even strength defensive WAR...break-even is 50). He's always on the wrong side of the puck. As competitive as he is in the offensive zone, he's that languid in his own end.

        Maybe I'm guilty of scapegoating a bit. There was a sequence last night in the third period where he got manhandled by Brent Burns in the corner. Jake actually took a poke at him, then went to the slot and got knocked on his arse by Burns.

        The Islanders pounded him into ineffectiveness a couple of postseasons ago.

        We just have so many of the same player...small and gritty. If I had my druthers, I'd rather have a bigger, stronger all-around player (like Lee) in that spot.

        Rick

Recent Posts

Penguins an Easy Mark(strom), No Match for the Devils

In keeping with last night’s low-event Metro clash with the Devils at the Prudential Center,…

18 hours ago

Penguins Update: Is This What Kyle Dubas Intended?

In Mel Brooks’ comedy, The Producers, Max Bialystock (brilliantly played by Zero Mostel) and his…

2 days ago

The Pen(guin) is Mightier, Prevails over Preds in OT

On Tuesday night, I thought our Penguins played perhaps their best game of the season,…

3 days ago

Penguins Update: Is Mike Sullivan Reinventing Himself?

Anyone who’s read PenguinPoop for any length of time knows black-and-gold coach Mike Sullivan doesn’t…

4 days ago

Penguins Acquire Joseph from the Blues

The Penguins added a new/old face to their roster today, acquiring defenseman Pierre-Olivier Joseph from…

4 days ago

Penguins Crown Kings, 3-2, in OT

I’ll be honest. I wasn’t too enthused about the Penguins’ chances for victory ahead of…

5 days ago