• Fri. Mar 6th, 2026

Penguins Fall to Those #%@! Islanders, 5-4, in OT

avatar

ByRick Buker

Feb 4, 2026

Funny how things work sometimes. On Monday night, the Penguins got Grade-A goaltending from Arturs Silovs to go with a sub-par overall performance. On Tuesday night, we gave a Grade-A effort, but received shaky netminding from our heretofore Rock of Gibraltar, Stuart Skinner.

That’s the way the puck bounces, I guess.

Too bad. Last night’s contest was truly a joy to watch. It had the riveting intensity and feel of a playoff contest. Except for some infrequent lapses, I thought we were pretty much on the Islanders from start to finish. Unfortunately the final result, a 5-4 overtime loss, had an all-too-familiar feel given our checkered history against the Fish Sticks.

The Pens took the lead at 12:09 of the first period on red-hot Anthony Mantha’s 20th goal of the campaign. Courtesy of a slick, one-hand-on-his-stick setup from Justin Brazeau.

It appeared we’d carry that lead into the first intermission when BANG-BANG, our hosts struck twice in the final 79 seconds. The go-ahead tally by rookie sensation Matthew Schaefer on a long-range bomb just four seconds before the horn.

The first indication that Skinner wasn’t on his game.

Unphased, the Pens came out with guns ablazin’ in the second period. Egor Chinakhov beat Ilya Sorokin with an absolute laser from inside the left circle at 3:52 to knot the score at 2-all.

We grabbed the lead at 14:09 on a goal by Bryan Rust that was part greasy, part WOW. Making like Mike Lange’s bulldozer in a construction yard, the gritty winger plowed his way along the boards before bouncing off a check by Schaefer and taking up residence near the net. Sidney Crosby followed the cycling suit and slipped a short pass to Rusty, who had the skill and smarts to bank the puck in off the back of Sorokin’s glove from behind the goal line.

Still, you had to know those pesky Isles weren’t going away. As former Pens tough guy Bob “Battleship” Kelly so colorfully and aptly noted, “they’re like a disease you can’t get rid of.” And so it was. With Ilya Solovyov providing a perfect and unfortunate screen in the slot, Mat Barzal beat Skinner from downtown 8:37 into the third period to tie the game at 3-apiece.

Again our guys shoved back. Just over two minutes later, Brazeau came up BIG again with a handsy redirect of a Brett Kulak shot/pass.

As much as I hoped that would be enough, I had a sinking feeling it wasn’t. Sure enough, with just under five minutes left in regulation Ryan Pulock walked through a seam and beat Skinner from the top of the left circle.

Still, my prayers were answered (sort of) when we hung on to earn a point and force overtime. However, Kulak gambled and drove to the net in the opening minute, in the process trapping all three Pens deep and sending Bo Horvat rambling up ice on a breakaway. To Kulak’s credit, he hustled like mad to get back, but Horvat had too much of a head start. The husky Isles forward beat Skinner high glove for the OT winner.

Puckpourri

While I’m on the subject, following a brilliant eight-game run, Big Stu’s shown his warts over his past two starts to the tune of 10 goals allowed on 43 shots. A Tristan Jarry-esque .767 save percentage.

Why Jarry-esque you ask? With an .872 save percentage out west, our former No. 1’s having troubles of his own. Recently, the Edmonton native had the temerity to call out his teammates for not defending hard enough. Never a good look for a goalie.

Perhaps I should be more gloom-and-doom, but there was so much to like about our play. We outshot the Isles, 35-23, which I think is a pretty fair representation of the action. We did everything but secure the second point.

The top line displayed some hop, thanks to Rusty’s return. We got contributions across the board, as nine skaters picked up at least a point. The Big Line (minus one) was huge (pun intended). Our fourth line? Pest city, as usual.

And Chinakhov? My goodness, is this kid impressive. Not just the world-class shot but the world-class speed as well. Eight goals in 17 games says it all.

This is the first time I had a chance to focus on Solovyov. I must say, I was impressed with what I saw—at least right up till the time he took away Skinner’s eyes on the third Islanders goal. Good size, good stick, good skate. Physical to boot.

Despite the loss, the Pens (28-15-12, 68 points) continue to hold second place in the Metro by a point over the Islanders with two games in hand. Beware the piping hot CBJ, who’ve won six in a row under new coach Rick Bowness. They’re in fourth place with 63 points.

Thank the Dear Lord we acquired Chinakhov before Bowness got to work with him.

We wrap up our pre-Olympics slate on Thursday night against the vastly improved Sabres in Buffalo. Should be a barn-burner. I’m still hoping to reach the break with 70 points.

In Memoriam

Jim Morrison, one of the early Pens, recently passed away at the ripe old age of 94. An all-star defenseman for Toronto in the ‘50s, “Pappy” toiled for nearly a decade in the AHL as a mainstay of the Quebec Aces before joining the Pens for two seasons (’69-71) at age 38.

3 thoughts on “Penguins Fall to Those #%@! Islanders, 5-4, in OT”
  1. Rick

    A few observations from the last two games against Ottawa and the Islanders:

    Both games were winnable, and it was discouraging to watch the struggles with passing, decision-making, and our overall ability to receive clean passes. I was particularly disappointed with the play of Shea and Malkin. This marked the second consecutive game in which a Shea puck mishandling directly led to a momentum-changing goal. It appears that these issues may be catching up to him, and while I am not a fan, I think most would agree there has been a noticeable decline in his play over the past several weeks.

    Additionally, I would like to see Coach Muse consider moving Geno to the second power-play unit.
    Also, I wanted to list giveaways by Penguin players.
    Witherspoon ( 77 ), Letang ( 73 ), Malkin ( 66 ), Karlsson ( 65 ), Crosby ( 60 )

    1. Hey Mike,

      Always good to hear from you. Now that he’s playing his off (right) side, Shea seems to be having more issues. Another site commented that he’s had to handle the puck a lot more on his backhand, which could be a contributing factor.

      I confess, when it comes to Shea I’m still kind of dazzled by how much faster he looks and how effective he’s been offensively. Like night and day from last season. Muse’s system really seems to have unlocked him. I know it’s not the be-all, end-all stat, but he is a plus-21, so he must be doing something right.

      Regarding the high number of giveaways, especially among the defense. The only thing I can think of is the defense seems to be handling the puck and joining the rush a lot more under Muse. With more opportunities to handle the puck, perhaps there are more opportunities to turn it over.

      How’s that for fuzzy logic? (lol)

      Hope you are well… 🙂

      Rick

      1. Rick
        I completely agree, and overall I appreciate the aggressive approach Muse has brought to the bench. That said, I see both positives and potential drawbacks in how it’s playing out. Given the personnel he currently has to work with, my concern is that the system is forcing more defensively minded players to handle the puck more frequently. When those players experience a bit of success, there’s a tendency for them to subtly alter their game, and in my opinion, that’s where issues can begin to surface.

        Shea has certainly done some good things with the puck, but it’s important for him to remain aware of his limitations and stay within his strengths as a player. I’ve also noticed that Clifton and Wortherspoon, at times, are holding onto the puck longer than necessary in an effort to make a play. That shift in decision-making can create risk and take them away from what they do best defensively.

        It’s important to emphasize just how impressive this has been, particularly given that the Penguins have already surpassed most preseason expectations. Muse deserves a great deal of credit for creating an environment where all four lines are contributing offensively. That’s what winning teams do!! Go Pen’s

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *