Categories: PenguinPoop

Penguins / Islanders Marred by Ugly Play and Horrible Officiating

Wow, I haven’t witnessed this kind of thing since the North Stars skated Basil McRae and Shane Churla together.  Obviously, the Islanders had vengeance on their minds.  Unfortunately, the Pens gave them ample opportunity to extract revenge as they spotted the Isles a 6 goal advantage.  Having a huge lead affords a team the opportunity to take some liberties.

The referees were damn near useless for this entire exchange.  They never took control of the game.  It seemed to really go down hill when Matt Martin sucker punched Max Talbot in the second period.  Yeah, I get it, he didn’t connect cleanly, but the intent was there on the level of what Todd Berutuzzi did to Steve Moore.   The referees could have set the tone at that point, but not so much.  The snowball starting going down hill.  After Gilles landed a flying elbow on Eric Tangradi and proceeded punching the now prone Tangradi, Michael Haley took the opportunity to engage Talbot.  After that scrum was broken up, the Refs apparently felt that Haley could conduct himself appropriately.   Why wouldn’t they think that as it was only his second fight of the game.  The officials let him go to the penalty box on his own recognisance.  Instead of peaceably going to the box, he decided to take a slight detour and skate to the other end of the ice and engage Brent Johnson in a fight.  This prompted Eric Godard to defend his goaltender and leave the bench to fight with Haley. 

The game went to hell from there.  322 penalty minutes.  The officials let it go there.  As bad as the officiating was during the game, I am quite interested in how the league handles some of the violations in terms of suspensions.  We know that Godard will be suspended for leaving the bench, but there had better be more suspensions.  Matt Martin’s attempted sucker punch should draw a good long suspension.  If Matt Cooke gets a 4 game suspension for his hit, the hit Trevor Gilles put on Tangradi should get a stiff penalty.  Hopefully, the league realizes how embarrassing this is for everyone, takes a stand and does something to prevent future such debacles. 

Let’s not forget, the Pens and Isles face off one more time on April 8.

Reg Dunlop

Recent Posts

Penguins Andrei Kuzmenko: Mistake or Master Stroke?

Throughout the summer, I’ve questioned some of Kyle Dubas’ moves. None more than signing free-agent…

4 days ago

How Will the Penguins’ Goaltending Hold Up?

In the wake of Kyle Dubas’ moves this summer, I’ve spend a great deal of…

5 days ago

Taking a Closer Look at the Penguins’ Forwards

For the most part, my take on the changes Kyle Dubas has wrought this summer…

6 days ago

Will Any of the Penguins’ Kids Become Stars?

About a week ago I posted an article projecting what the Penguins' lineup might look…

1 week ago

Penguins Update: No Room at the Inn for the Kids

If you’ve been reading PenguinPoop over the summer, you’ve no doubt picked up on the…

2 weeks ago

Is There a Rationale Behind the Penguins’ New-Look Defense?

With nothing in particular to write about, I thought I’d once again focus on the…

2 weeks ago