As I was about to respond to a comment to my last article by Other Rick about the state of our defense, I decided to delve into the blue-line makeup of recent Stanley Cup winners as a way of demonstrating what an effective, balanced defense should look like. After all, if anyone should know a thing or two about constructing a defense, it’s teams that have hoisted Lord Stanley’s chalice.
As the old saying goes, a picture is worth a thousand words. Or in this case, a series of tables. I’ve listed the top six defensemen for each of the past four Cup champions, along with their height and weight and a brief description of each player’s basic attributes.
To absolutely no surprise (or at least not mine), none of these defensive corps bear even a passing resemblance to our current mix of rearguards.
Without further ado, here goes:
2023-24 PANTHERS
| Player | Ht./Wt. | Attributes |
| Forsling | 6’0″ 186 | Puck-mover, all-arounder |
| Montour | 6’0″ 194 | Puck-mover, all-arounder, physical |
| Ekblad | 6’4″ 215 | Puck-mover, all-arounder, physical |
| Ekman-Larsson | 6’2″ 200 | Puck-mover, all-arounder |
| Mikkola | 6’4″ 209 | Stay-at-home, physical |
| Kulikov | 6’1″ 201 | Stay-at-home, physical |
2022-23 GOLDEN KNIGHTS
| Player | Ht./Wt. | Attributes |
| Theodore | 6’2″ 197 | Puck-mover |
| Pietrangelo | 6’3″ 215 | Puck-mover, all-arounder |
| Whitecloud | 6’2″ 207 | All-arounder |
| Martinez | 6’1″ 210 | Stay-at-home |
| Hague | 6’6″ 230 | Stay-at-home, physical |
| McNabb | 6’4″ 215 | Stay-at-home, physical |
2021-22 AVALANCHE
| Player | Ht./Wt. | Attributes |
| Makar | 5’11” 187 | Norris Trophy puck-mover |
| Toews | 6’1″ 191 | Puck-mover, all-arounder |
| Byram | 6’1″ 190 | Puck-mover, all-arounder |
| Manson | 6’3″ 218 | Stay-at-home, physical |
| Johnson, Erik | 6’4″ 225 | Stay-at-home, physical |
| Johnson, Jack | 6’1″ 227 | Stay-at-home |
2020-21 LIGHTNING
| Player | Ht./Wt. | Attributes |
| Hedman | 6’7″ 244 | Norris Trophy puck-mover, all-arounder |
| Sergachev | 6’1″ 217 | Puck-mover, all-arounder |
| Cernák | 6’4″ 224 | Puck-mover, all-arounder, physical |
| McDonagh | 6’1″ 215 | All-arounder |
| Savard | 6’1″ 235 | Stay-at-home, physical |
| Rutta | 6’3″ 204 | Stay-at-home, physical |
The trend continued back through the ’19-20 Lightning, the ’18-19 Blues and the ’17-18 Caps. The Blues in particular boasted a HUGE, physical defense that featured the likes of Pietrangelo, Colton Parayko (6’6” 228), Jay Bouwmeester (6’4” 206), Joel Edmundson (6’5” 221) and ex-Pen Robert Bortuzzo (6’4” 216).
Okay, now compare these groups with what figures to be our top-six this season.
2024-25 PENGUINS (PROJECTED)
| Player | Ht./Wt. | Attributes |
| Karlsson | 6’0″ 190 | Norris Trophy puck-mover |
| Letang | 6’0″ 201 | Puck-mover, physical |
| Pettersson | 6’3″ 177 | All-arounder, physical |
| Graves | 6’5″ 220 | All-arounder |
| Grzelcyk | 5’10” 176 | Puck-mover, all-arounder |
| Aho | 5’10” 186 | Puck-mover |
You’ll notice immediately that as a collective we’re almost totally bereft of a stay-at-home presence, not to mention size and physicality. (Frankly, it was a stretch to list Letang and Pettersson as physical players.)
Although the imbalances in our defensive makeup would improve slightly if 6-foot-3, 200-pound Jack St. Ivany (stay-at-home, physical) displaces Aho, given coach Mike Sullivan’s preference for puck-movers there’s no guarantee of that happening.
In closing, I hope this provides an objective look into the shortcomings of our defense, and why I’m so critical of the way Kyle Dubas has constructed it.
As the Penguins continue to stumble through the throes of what for all the world…
In a battle of the birds in Anaheim last night, it was the homestanding Ducks…
The Penguins halted their four-game losing streak last night with a 5-2 victory over the…
To borrow from an old Tom Petty classic, the Penguins are free fallin.’ Losers of…
A couple of weeks ago I wrote an article where I confessed to my envy…
It wasn’t all that long ago I was singing praises to Kyle Dubas. Starting with…