Categories: PenguinPoop

Penguins Playoff Update: The Comeback Kids?

The time for a more traditional post had long since passed when I got to wondering. How many times have the Penguins rallied from a 3-games-to-2 deficit to win a playoff series?

I decided to do some digging. The Pens have overcome 3-2 series deficits (or worse) to emerge victorious six times in their storied postseason history. Coincidence or not, they accomplished the feat each time they won a Cup.

Playoff Year Opponent Deficit Round
1991* New Jersey 3-2 Division Semifinals
1992* Washington 3-1 Division Semifinals
1995 Washington 3-1 Conference Quarterfinals
1999 New Jersey 3-2 Conference Quarterfinals
2001 Buffalo 3-2 Conference Semifinals
2009* Detroit 3-2 Cup Finals
* Won Stanley Cup

I confess. I wasn’t feeling real positive about our chances. Especially with Trevor Daley out. Then I look at what’s happened before. And I start to believe.

Here are some reasons why.

Backup goalie Frank Pietrangelo emerged from the shadows in ’91 to steal Games 6 and 7 from the Devils. Mario Lemieux and a host of Hall-of-Famers trapped the Caps into submission in ’92. Tough guy Frankie Leroux set up a Game 5 overtime winner in ’95 to ignite an amazing comeback.

A hobbled Jaromir Jagr scored two huge goals in Game 6 to turn the tide against Jersey in ’99.  Light-scoring Daruis Kasparaitis slashed the Sabres with an improbable Game 7 overtime winner in ’01.

Rob Scuderi stopped three shots from point-blank range in the waning seconds of Game 6 to preserve a must-win over Detroit in the ’09 Finals. Max Talbot made like a “Superstar” to notch both black-and-gold goals in the Cup-clincher.

Tonight?

Perhaps kid goalie Matt Murray pitches a shutout. Maybe Evgeni Malkin busts loose for a hat trick. Or Sidney Crosby nets an OT-winner.

Or Phil Kessel. Or Carl Hagelin. Or Nick Bonino. Or Matt Cullen.

You never know who might rise to the occasion in heroic fashion.

It’s happened before. It can happen again.

GO PENS!

Rick Buker

Recent Posts

Announcing My Semi-Retirement from PenguinPoop (Part II)

Back in September 2024, I announced my semi-retirement from blogging. No sooner did I click…

4 days ago

Penguins Extend Evgeni Malkin

The Penguins have signed franchise icon Evgeni Malkin to an extension for the 2026-27 season.…

1 week ago

Calder Cup Update: Checking on the Baby Penguins

Having disposed of Hershey and Springfield in Rounds 1 and 2 of the Calder Cup…

1 week ago

2026 Draft: Penguins 1st Round Player Options Breakdown Part 3

Welcome to part 3 of my series breaking down players the Penguins might be able…

2 weeks ago

2026 Draft: Penguins 1st Round Player Options Breakdown Part 2

Welcome to part two of my breakdown, analysis, and review of the possible first-round options…

2 weeks ago

Penguins Prospect Bill Zonnon Shines (Ilyin Too)

During the 2025 Entry Draft, I confess I was bitterly disappointed at first when the…

2 weeks ago